PDA

View Full Version : Stupid error in judgement!!!


Stodelle
07-13-2004, 11:37 PM
Alright, I have to come clean. I did something stupid this weekend that has not stopped nagging me.

I went out Spearfishing solo this weekend. That really isn't too much of a no-no because here on Maui we have alot of spearos, so there is always someone fairly close-by to where you are diving. (I know, I know)

Anyway, I came across a nice little ledge in about 25 feet of water. it's a ledge I always hit as I've gotten some decent fish there. Well, I dive down and peak under and see a whole school of Menpachi (Soldierfish) which are VERY good eating. So, I sight in on the biggest one, take a shot, and whack.....the spear sticks into the reef at the back of the ledge/cave.

It is about 18" tall, but it goes back about a good 5 or 6 feet. I tried working my shaft loose but it didn't budge. I had to resurface several time (freediving) while trying to work it loose. I told myself, "This is BS, I'm not leaving a $50 shaft here in this ledge. So, I dive down, slide through the ledge opening into the back of this cave, and work the shaft loose. I get it out, slide backwards and make for the surface.

Later, it hits me how I violated one of my own rules of doing something stupid. I have worked rescue and recovery for many years and it always amazed me how the "victims" always seemed to do something stupid and cause their families alot of grief.

As I was driving home with my wife and daughter in the car, I couldn't help but think the pain they would have gone through if something would have happened. All for a lousy $50 shaft!!!!

Call it therapy, but I just had to post it to hopefully make somebody aware of how a stupid little error in judgement in the heat of the moment could have been a major turning point for everyone.

I know I will think twice next time, but for now I am truly disapointed in myself. Oh well, at least I can say I "lived and learned".

NoobDiver
07-13-2004, 11:49 PM
Thats pretty (dont know the word for it) that you realized that in the water before doing it again. It's always easy to look back and realize how stupid something was , ie. going after a 50$ shaft, but its not easy to think about while in the process. Props bro!

Johnoly
07-14-2004, 12:52 AM
Big props to you!!

Not a single experienced hunter on this board that hasn't pushed it to the limits over a kill. Me included, but it's the lesson that I've learned that makes me smile when huge AJ shows up along with a couple of bulls and makes you hold your shot rather than get in a fight that no one wins.

Steel Shootin'
07-14-2004, 06:57 AM
Good point....it's never worth it. Even if I am on SCUBA, if I am going into a situation where I can get hung-up, I find the closest diver, point to my eyes ("watch me"), and only then do I try to extract the fish or spear. If I can't find a diver, then the fish or spear stays where it is. I have known people who could not back out of a ledge because their tanks got hung-up.

On deep dives, I have found that nitrogen can really impair your judgment, even if you don't feel "narced" in the traditional sense. I have done things that by the time I get to my safety stop I think, "Why the hell did I do that?" Part of diving safer (for me), is knowing in advance that I am prone to being overly aggressive at times, so that I can stop myself when something seems like a good idea at depth.

Thunderball
07-16-2004, 08:03 AM
If it ever happens again, you can leave the shaft in the reef wall as a sort of "icon" to your risky behavior. That way, every time you re-visit your ledge, you'll see that shaft stuck in the wall and say "I love my wife, and my family, and it's good to be alive."

Daddy_Jeffy
07-16-2004, 01:13 PM
Did you get the Fish?

Stodelle
07-16-2004, 10:16 PM
No!!!! That's one of the other bad things about this incident was that I went home with zip!!! But I was alive.

chicotrout
07-17-2004, 03:07 AM
What makes the risks that we take so dangerous is the fact that they are only "stupid" if something goes wrong...otherwise they are always seen as calculated.
My grandpa' used to say...Always ask yourself if you approve of what you are about to do, if there is any hesitation or doubt in your response, you're more than likely trying to rationalize something "stupid" away.
As far as I'm concerned, that is the smartest shit I ever heard. Never got myself into trouble when by listening to his advise. The hard part is listening to that damn little voice that always wants to put a kink in your plans!:mad: :D

Thanks for sharing.

spear_friend
08-09-2004, 11:13 PM
hey stodelle.
if you ever get into that situation again, just click that switch off, ill give you fish or a shaft. And thats for anybody.always dive safe, never put yourself in that situation, EVEN IF YOU THINK YOU CAN
I DONT EAT FISH , JUST LOVE THE THRILL OF SPEARING THEM .....i give fish away on every dive .Welll ,unless its my trophy fish...