PDA

View Full Version : Xtreme Misinformation. Venice, Louisiana August 8-10


Dive4Blood
08-11-2003, 11:57 AM
This weekend I along with Spearboard members Bubblejunkie, Shooter Dan, Reef Raider, Merk, and Seastalker booked an overnighter rig spearfishing trip through Xtreme Charters which is a booking agent for many of the charter boats in Venice, LA. Halfway through my twelve hour ride home very early this morning I made a checklist in my head of the bill of goods sold to us by Xtreme partially to keep from falling asleep, and partially as a head's up for those that want to book a trip through them.

Price/Trip Length/No. of Tanks
Most of the people on this Board know I set up myself and help run 12-15 weekend trips per year to the Fla Middlegrounds aboard the Jolly Rogers 2, and have been doing so for a number of years now. I'd like to think that since I'm frequently in Xtreme's position as the "booking agent", that I would be pretty clear with my questions, and I would have the trip's expectations pretty well laid out with them. When I first called, I indicated that we wanted a trip similar to what we run, leave Friday night come back Sunday, at least six tanks. No problem I was told, $425 each including a $100 dep, and they'll even talk to the captain to see if we can bring an extra tank or two. Cool, I'm psyched, $600 check sent, I reread the book Helldiver's Rodeo, and now I'm chomping at the bit for the trip. I call to touch base a couple months before the trip. When I review the trip price with Xtreme (deposit cashed at this point) the price changes to $100 PER HOUR with the explanation that this is what ALL charterboats charge in Venice. I'm already hooked on doing the trip, and getting reeled in fast, so I bend, settling for a 30 hour trip @ $3000 ($500pp) leaving Sat morn, and coming back Sun afternoon. At the dock Sat morning our Capt Troy Wetzel (who seemed to take in stride getting caught in all this crossfire) takes a look at our gear, and says he was told this would only be a four tank trip. 1500 mile round trip, and 24 hours total drive time for four tanks? It almost came to some of the guys getting close to saying **** it, that Capt Troy Ok'ed the "extra tanks"

Food-During the initial call, Xtreme said they would take care of most of the food with cajun specialties like duck boudin, venison roasts and sausages being provided. Post-deposit it changed to just one meal. On the drive over to Venice, I was called and told that they would bring us some Popeye's chicken (no joke!!!). On the boat Capt Troy told us he didn't do any food, but considering the circumstances he brought along some venison/wild hog sausages which turned out awesome. Thanks to Bubblejunkie who brought some mini-season bugs, and Seastalker who picked up some last minute steaks.

Tuna Fishing- It was always understood that we would fish for yellowfin tuna during our trip. I even was called on the cell phone en route to Venice, and told that we would be tying up to Medusa, a deepwater floater rig, to fish all Sat night for tuna. As it turned out not one line was put in the water for yellowfins the entire trip. The crew explained that it would take too long out of the trip to effectively target them. The fishing that we did do consisted of deep drops in 250'. It was extremely slow, but Shooter Dan and Seastalker who had electric reels managed 4 beautiful American Reds between 18#-20# which was pretty much the sum of the hook and line catch.

Depths-In spite of most of the group being tech certified, Xtreme insisted that we keep a 130' max depth so we gassed up our nitrox appropriately. Capt Troy was expecting us however to dive deeper, and would have had no problem with us doing so. Our nitrox mixes became our undoing as you will soon read.

So enough bitching. What about the trip? I have to say that the experience of diving the rigs was awesome. They are everywhere you look in every direction, in all different shapes and sizes. After a 20-30 foot murk layer of dirty green water it opens up to unlimited blue vis. The diffuse light penetrating the network of support columns, cross members, and pipes combined with the ever present weird echoes, and constant clanging of machinery from above gave the whole scene a very cool sci-fi/ horror film vibe. The murk layer usually had good amounts of regular size mangos, and the upper blue water layer usually had swarms of big sheepshed and triggers. These triggers could kick their Middlegrounds brethren's asses. They are huge, and very aggressive, constantly trying to bite you even when on the stringer. Huge shools of bait, lookdowns, jack crevalle, and tropical fish were everywhere. Amberjack and cobia were sporadic, I was expecting monster schools of each on every dive. When we would dive to our max nitrox depths of 130-150 feet we would almost always see trophy grouper and red snapper at 200 ft plus in large quantities swimming below us. Bubblejunkie did manage to lure up a 36# gag and a 26# red snapper on the first dive, but that was really the only true trophies speared. Personally I shot three good size cobias which was cool since we don't see them that frequently in the Middlegrounds, some nice 7#-10# scamp groupers, average barjacks, feedove some nice mangos, a 30#ish aj, and an Igloo 128 cooler full of big triggers and sheepshead. I'm sure the other guys will post their personal catches.

The boat we went on (Kingfish) was a very basic, yet clean and functional boat. I like that they have a grill, and run A/C in the cabin at night, two things I need to work on to be standard on the Jolly Rogers 2. It has a huge deck area that lends itself very well to spearfishing. Capt Troy Wetzel proved to be very friendly and helpful after everyone cooled down from the initial miscommunication about the trip. He told us that this is is the tail end of the rig tank spearfishing season since most of the rigs have received heavy pressure all summer, and several large spearfishing rodeos had just recently occurred, a detail Xtreme must have forgotten to tell us. The prime time from what Troy said is early April to early June where alot of the fish that are now in the deeper depths are available, and not wary in the shallower portions of the rigs.

Am I disapponted? Bigtime. Would I go again? In a heartbeat. I just chalk up this trip as a learning experience. My next trip (Bubblejunkie is already in too) will be in late spring, and I AM GOING TO DEAL WITH CAPT. TROY WETZEL DIRECT. He offered to bring a compressor to fill air, and let us scrub with our 80% nitrox pony bottles to allow the capability to hit the deeper depths for 6-8 drops a day. Buyer beware if you deal with Xtreme. Standing by.
Shooter Dan, please post some pics, when you get over being pissed at us for ruining the last spot ;) :rolleyes: . Standing by.

AJ Suarez


Lousiana Offshore Fishing
Capt Troy Wetzel
504-834-5380
www.captaintroywetzel.com
troywetzel@cox.net

Shooter Dan
08-11-2003, 12:08 PM
I'm over it & I'm working on those pictures now.

We did fish some at nite, but the take wasn't that spectactular.

I did manage up 3 American Reds around 20# and finished off my daily limit including the 14#er I shot earlier.

Seastalker had a nice 20# red as well. 200' drops, the electric Reels did the job and I would highly recommend them to everyone who goes.

fernandezh
08-11-2003, 12:09 PM
AJ,
you mistyped the website. it is www.captaintroywetzel.com

Damn, I am sorry to hear that you were so disappointed about the trip. I remember how psyched you were about going on it. I learned that same lesson when I went diving in Bali several years ago when I booked a charter through a "middle-man" who jacked up the prices so he could get a cut for linking me up with a dive charter. He charged me $100 for a 2 tank trip that actually cost $30 if I had booked directly through the charter.

Sounds like though you still had the chance to get some nice fish nonetheless. Looking forward to seeing the pics.

Hector

LSUBigL
08-11-2003, 12:11 PM
Hmm..this is interesting. I am scheduled to go with Troy in late September. I'm a little concerned that the fishing will not be very good after reading your post.

What were the depths of the rigs that you dove? Do you know what rig block you were in?

I would imagine that you could probably settle the disagreements with Al Walker directly. He regularly posts on www.rodnreel.com

Big L

Dive4Blood
08-11-2003, 12:23 PM
I stand corrected Hector. I just typed the wesbsite address verbatim on Troy's business card.

LSU, the rigs we dove on were in 250-300 ft. I don't know what rig block we were in, but do remember that one of the one's we dove was MP299. I have nothing to settle with Xtreme, I will take my future business directly to the boat operator. Good luck, give a shout if you ever want to dive the Middlegrounds. Late fall and winter is the best time for steel slinging out there.

AJ Suarez

Shooter Dan
08-11-2003, 12:27 PM
The King Fish Set Up

http://www.momentoffame.com/snapshots/MomentOfFame/l47887.jpg

Night Fishing
Seastalker and Shooter Dan

http://www.momentoffame.com/snapshots/MomentOfFame/l47888.jpg

Shooter Dan
08-11-2003, 12:35 PM
Dive4Blood with some Scamps

http://www.momentoffame.com/snapshots/MomentOfFame/l47889.jpg

Jerry's First Drop

http://www.momentoffame.com/snapshots/MomentOfFame/l47890.jpg

I have to say that Capt. Troy is an outstanding Captain and the trip was a learning experience.

Free diving the saftey stop zone isn't that bad out of turn, but diving the upper 50 out of turn really turned the deco stop scrap shooting into real scrap shooting. I took a 10 mango on one stop and always loaded up on 7 & 6 lb trigs.

Shooter Dan
08-11-2003, 12:41 PM
Merk,

What's up with that shot behind D4B?

LSUBigL
08-11-2003, 12:48 PM
MP 299??? I'm glad you guys are alright. There was a report recently of some Hydrogen Sulfide at 299 in high concentrations, way above the lethal level. We were five miles west of y'all at MP 72. 72 is in about 130 feet of water and 299 is in 200+

Did you dive the massive rig that is made up of about 10 structures with connecting walkways?

Dive4Blood
08-11-2003, 12:50 PM
The H2S at MP299 must be the reason why it looks like I have a possessed alien head growing from my shoulder in the scamp pic. Yes we did dive that big interconnected rig.

ROCK BOTTOM
08-11-2003, 04:02 PM
Sorry about the problems with the dive trip.

Nobody up here dives with NITROX while speardiving the rigs. Someone should have thought about that one.

Tell me more about the dive trip. What size were the cobia? No big AJs? Any current to speak of?

Charlestondivin
08-11-2003, 05:58 PM
Damn nice fish Jerry.

Screen Name
08-11-2003, 08:18 PM
Great report D4b.

Nice Fkn fish, Jerry! Any dive you get out of the water with a 36 lb Gag, 26 lb Red Snap, and a big Sheepshead is a memorable freaking dive!

Sorry about the "surprises" you guys received.

Hector, I believe yer 22 lb "Clearwater" snapper is in danger dude. :D

kitefisherman
08-11-2003, 08:39 PM
All good looking fish there.

Glad to hear that you guys made the best of it and found a way to deal direct for the next time.

Wish some of the LA guys would comment on whether your experience was typical in how non-locals are treated and any advice for planning a trip to LA. Sounds like they have some great shooting there. Would like to try it myself someday.

fishsticker
08-11-2003, 08:47 PM
Good job fellas....sorry you got f***ed by the middle man. Hope you have a better experience next time.

fernandezh
08-12-2003, 12:43 AM
I actually shot that snapper out of Alabama with Gulfdiver's boat the Deeper Peeper. I will gladly bow out to a shooter like bubblejunkie who now has the title for having the largest red snapper as his beat mine by 4 lbs. Good job Jerry!

Hector

Dive4Blood
08-12-2003, 07:25 AM
I have no problem with paying $500, with bringing my own food, and not tuna fishing if it's not feasible, IF I'M TOLD UP FRONT!! The problem I had is that everytime I was in contact with Xtreme the story changed. Being that I was the point man that organized the trip, any ****-ups ultimately roll downhill to me, and I am embarrassed that some of the guys were pissed over the whole situation. Anyone who deals with me setting up their Jolly Rogers 2 trip knows that I go out of my way to give them the honest lowdown on what is expected, what to bring, and answer any question or concern thoroughly.

Kite, I definitely want to go back next spring, and would love for you to come with us. Bubblejunkie and Shooter Dan have thrown their hats in the ring as well. I spoke with Fishunta' before the trip who said to definitely put him down for the next one. Hindsight is always 20/20. With what I know now, the next trip should be run smoother.

AJ Suarez

kitefisherman
08-12-2003, 08:31 AM
AJ: Please put me on the list - I'll go. Thanks

Merk
08-12-2003, 08:35 AM
I must have taken a hit, when I came out of the water after my third dive my eyes were acting a little funny. Couldn't have everyone focusing on those two fat scamps now could we.

My highlight for the trip was coming face to face with a 70-80lb AJ when I was stringing up one of his kids. He only showed his face once so I didn't get a shot off but I'm actually glad I wasn't able to pop his ass. I was at 132 feet in the middle of the rig with no structure within 40 feet when I saw him. If I didn't get a kill shot he would have drug my ass down to the bottom with a 32% mix. Not good. Needless to say it got my blood pumping.

I did see several 40-50lb grouper all while sitting on the cross bars at 134 feet banging my stringer on my gun calling the big boys from the deep. The vis was so good the fish would come up to about 40 feet below me and look then turn and head back down to the bottom.

Did mange to fill the stringer with huge triggers, sheepshead, average goes, average scamps, AJs, legal grouper and red snapper on every dive. Just didn't see the bigger fish that I was hoping for. I guess it's the wrong time of year.

There is not doubt these rigs get hit hard with fishing & diving pressure. Many of the fish we brought on board had hooks in their gills or mouth.

I believe Captain Troy fishes and dives these same rigs on a regular basis so it's definitely not virgin territory. He mentioned a charter he had the week before when they caught their two day limit of 64 reds between 14-36lbs. No wonder we only caught 4.

D4B - thank you for setting up the trip I had a great time. Depending on the circumstances and time of year I may be up for round two at the Rodeo.

lukepaige
08-12-2003, 11:38 AM
I've always heard good things about Troy's operations. It sucks that ya'll didn't get to tuna fish. At this time of the year the fish around the rigs are usually a little weary and deep. The farther west you go the better the fishing gets. The Venice area gets hit pretty hard. If ya'll decide to come again I would definately try to come for the opening day of snapper season. This year we were able to free dive and kill 12-15 pound snapper on opening day. The cobia also start showing up around that time.

Dive4Blood
08-12-2003, 01:03 PM
Capt Troy Wetzel called today to thank me for his business, and to let me know that he had a good time diving with us. That's pretty impressive, and shows good business acumen on his part. With the amount of people getting a hold of me to get set up for the next round, we may have to do two trips instead of one. The sacrifices I have to make for you people ;) !

Luke, so come April when the red snapper season opens up in 2004, they're big, plentiful, and dumb as a box of rocks? How's it like then for gags, aj's, and BIG cobia?

AJ Suarez

lukepaige
08-12-2003, 04:08 PM
The snapper are definately "stupid" at that time of year. That goes for the rest of the fish as well. The water temps are cool to cold in South Louisiana terms (I think 65 degrees opening day above thermocline). That's f#$%ing cold for me. The fish are higher in the water column with the cool temperatures and lack of fishing pressure. Our biggest cobia of the year came early, 44 lbs, not a monster but pretty good. One trip in early may we shot 8 lemons freediving and probably saw 30 more.

FredT
08-12-2003, 04:37 PM
Originally posted by Dive4Blood
Luke, so come April when the red snapper season opens up in 2004, they're big, plentiful, and dumb as a box of rocks? How's it like then for gags, aj's, and BIG cobia?

AJ Suarez

April is a bit early for cobia. The run is when the water temps make about 70°F. This works both ways. Late april/may they are heading west, late October/November they are heading east. Bigger ones are usually on the eastbound run. Water temp is the key though.

BTW I think this year one weekend in April was diveable.

Definitely go for the compressor next trip, and a bit of normoxic helium trimix is a possibility if you intend to chase those critters down deep.

My favorite time to hunt off here was February, but the Feds have now closed season on eveything worth taking then. Gags are open, as are a few of the smaller snapper species, but the big sows are up shallow then and not very skittish. In April you'll have a 3 in 4 chance of a trip to Venice for breakfast. By coming later this year you hit the lottery on weather. The sows are starting to get skittsh by April, and the gags are starting to move offshore.

Cobia, AJ and cuda are the larger summer fare here, with the occasional inattentive grouper or snapper of several species. Kings and other blue water fish will occasionally make an appearance. I've taken big sows almost year round, but they are harder to find and deeper in the summer.

FT

fernandezh
08-12-2003, 04:38 PM
I concur about the dumb snapper bit. I shot mine just a few days into the season and saw one that was around 40# staring at me just 2 feet away and swam off when I was reloading

lukepaige
08-14-2003, 12:33 PM
The weather is always going to be a bitch when you want to dive. The past two years have been beautiful on opening day of snapper season. Clean water is usually close to shore at this time of year.

Fishknuts
08-14-2003, 04:26 PM
the do start out pretty shallow but once the pressure starts they go deep quick. average depth out of grand isle for snapper shootin is 150 + with a bottom of 300' and of course most will hang out at the 200' mark.

Fishknuts
08-14-2003, 04:30 PM
that sucks that yall had a chitty trip. yall should consult a little more with some locals before booking yalls next trip....... but our spearfishing is absolutly world class. yall should come in february and march for some free diving for wahoo and tuna. they chum up pretty easy........

rigdvr
08-16-2003, 07:58 PM
you are not the only one that has had these problems. However, having dove with Troy as well as Bill Delabar of Xtreme they are 2 of the nicest people I have ever met.

Be careful dealing with Troy direct as that can cause its own set of problems...pm me if you want to know more(or Chad Carney...he was there)

As you found out the diving can be deep at times here. Early is good, the vis is lower, the seas are rougher, and the fish are les timid. Just bear in mind the amount of fronts we get. This year we canceled many trips in April, May and early June due to seas...