PDA

View Full Version : A soldier's view from Iraq


richhermes
03-27-2007, 03:38 PM
A high school classmate of mine is currently in Iraq and sent this update. Thought some would like to read a soldier's POV.


Dear Family and Friends,

I apologize for the mass e-mail, but I wanted to write as many as I could to provide an update, and let you know that I’ve been back in Iraq for a month now. While over here last year I really enjoyed hearing from a lot of people, and the several e-mail exchanges really were a great distraction. So if you have questions or updates of your own, please drop a line.

I am now the Executive Officer (or XO) of 5th ANGLICO (Air Naval Gunfire Liaison Company), and we are headquartered at Al Asad Air Base in Western Iraq, but we have teams spread throughout the Euphrates River Valley. Our mission is to link USMC as well as Air Force and Army aircraft with U.S. Army and Iraqi Army units on the ground and to serve as a liaison to the Marine headquarters that is in charge of the Al Anbar Province. It’s a very diverse and interesting mission to say the least. You can check out our web site, but honestly it is still very modest and a work in progress. We plan to add a lot of photos of the Marines and Sailors over here and their families as they do things together back in Okinawa. https://public.iiimefdm.usmc.mil/5anglico/default.aspx

Last year I commanded a platoon that varied from 40-60 Marines and Sailors depending on the ever changing missions, and I lived at the headquarters of the 1st Iraqi Army Division in Habbaniyah. Great experience and I had a chance to visit there again and see some friends and familiar faces when I led the advance party on a tour of all of our team locations. Unfortunately (or fortunately depending on perspective) that may probably the last time I leave “Camp Cupcake” for a while. It really charges your batteries to see the Marines out there doing a tremendous job, sometimes under tough conditions, and – using one of our colloquialisms – it’s a “varsity mission” that they do every day.

As far as ‘how things are going’ over here… well I’m happy to see and report improvements. I first got here in Feb 2006, and when I went home, I read books critical of the war effort because I was worried that we were just on a treadmill, and I needed some perspective. I returned in Feb 2007, and some things are stagnant, but others are noticeably improved. Now I only know about Baghdad of what I read in the news like you, and I have no clue about the rest of Iraq we never hear about, but I feel pretty comfortable with what’s happening in Al Anbar. Here’s a few vignettes:
- A Marine major who was finishing his second tour in two years (much like me) in Ramadi stated unequivocally to me, “We’re defeating the insurgency in Al Anbar” when I was there inspecting the equipment we were inheriting from him. He has keen insight, and I consider him a realist.
- The Chaplain at Mass this past Sunday talked about how last week he was walking the streets in Hit with the Army Task Force Commander there, and he spoke with a teacher, then a man who said he was a barber. So the Army lieutenant colonel shed his helmet and flak jacket and got a haircut and invited him on his base saying he had a lot of soldiers that needed a haircut. Last year, Hit was bad, but they had a battle in January of this year in which a bunch of foreign fighters were killed, and ever since then, the place has been quiet.
- I enjoyed a cigar last night with some officers who just came into our camp in preparation to go back on a ship and return to California. Their battalion worked in the area between where I am and the Sryian border, and they said it was fairly quiet the whole time. They did have several tough casualties, but compared to two years ago when it was referred to as the “Wild West”, this is a dramatic improvement.
- The Sunnis out here have decided that they have had enough of the Al Qaeda and the foreign fighters, and they are publicly siding with the Americans. The “Surge” is still on going, but it really does seem hopeful especially since the Sunni Sheiks are working with the Americans. As a result, there are a lot more Police, and the recruiting for the Army is picking up, although they are still woefully undermanned. The Sheiks have all the power; when they say its okay to join the Police and the Army, then they do it. The best part of the surge is that it will allow us to go to places that have been safe havens and hold them rather than raid those areas and leave s we’ve done in the past.
- We are changing some fundamental tactics and how we operate. Not sure how or if it will be better, but coupled with cooperation from the sheiks, it really has promise.

The insurgents are still really nasty. Did you see this in the news? A bomber who got through the checkpoint because he had children in the car then ran away and blew it up with the kids in the car. I’m seeing attacks in areas that were calm last year, but that could be because we’re there now. More noticeably is the stark decrease in attacks in hot spots like Fallujah and Ramadi.

All that said, this is still a dirty war, and good men and women are still dying. Maybe I’m seeing a good week, or a good month, and next month an event could happen that flushes all this progress down the toilet. Maybe we’ll pull the plug on this too quickly, and the Army will fall into sectarian lines. The Iraqi Army is good and growing, but not that good and not growing that quickly. And the Police are there, but a lot of those guys were probably planting IEDs a few months ago. Sounds like the government is getting its act together and talking reconciliation, but a few assassinations could mess everything up. As one Iraqi said, “All we can do is hope.”

For me, I miss my family terribly, but I wouldn’t want to be anywhere else right now. I’m glad to be doing my part, and then I’ll be even happier to go home. Life is good on Okinawa. In my short 5 months at home Nina and I played a lot of golf, spent a lot of time hiking along the rocky coastline at low tide with the kids, and enjoying some tasty cocktails by the fire outside.

I went on longer than I planned, so I’ll end it by saying if you want to write, my address is:
5th ANGLICO, Det A
Unit 38552
FPO AP 96606-8552

Take care and Semper Fi, Bruce

Bill McIntyre
03-27-2007, 04:01 PM
Thanks, that's very interesting. I hope he is correct about things turning around.

Its timely that you should post this including the mention of tribal leaders turning against Al Queda. This morning's LA Times quoted our departing Ambassador as saying the same thing, but also admitting that it was not all of the tribal leaders. And then here is an article that I just read on the NYT site saying that one of the tribal leaders who opposed Al Queda got killed today.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/27/world/middleeast/27cnd-iraq.html?hp

It was also of personal interest to me that this guy was XO of 5th ANGLICO. I was in !st ANGLICO when I applied for flight school and got orders to it, and I think my timing was good. It was a lot safer to be a jet pilot in Vietnam than to be in ANGLICO.

Mobile Diver
03-27-2007, 04:07 PM
Nice post. It is very refreshing to get the truth.

bruce_s
03-27-2007, 05:49 PM
Thanks for sharing that with us.I am very proud of the job these guys are doing under tough circumstances.The children thing tells you the depths of the hatred involved here.The sooner we can have the iraqis take over the better.
On another note like the soldier states I have heard that sop's have been rewritten and updated to reflect the modern type of war we face.This is especially true with the elite forces there.This is something else that can be taken from this.Invaluable experience.

Low-Mu
03-27-2007, 07:24 PM
Well I'm sitting here right now in Fallujah and agree with all of the things your friend said. Iraq is a long and slow process. I would say we are winning, even though all you see in the news is more Americans getting killed day by day. I look at the death toll once a week when I give a IED brief and this week alone in my area it was 5 U.S. KIA and 50 terrorist killed. I believe we need to continue building up Iraqi troops and then we need to pull out of here. Not because I don't agree with Iraq, which I do, but because Iraqi's are lazy as hell. If we don't pull out they are just gonna mooch off of us as much as they can and not do anything until they have to. As far as SOP's I'd say the terrorists are doing pretty good in that area as well. They video tape U.S. forces and know excatly what they can get away with. If one of them get's shot, all they have to do is throw down their gun and run around the corner, come at you from another direction and you have to give them medical aid. The media is the biggest problem. The terrorist's know about our secret counter measures because some jackass on late night news gives himself the title of expert and talks about things he shouldn't, on national television just for his fifteen minutes of fame and the poor marines who are put up for trial because a video of them executing a wounded insurgent when their buddies were blow up by a grenade in the same circumstance a day before. I'll I can say is be patient. If we just pull out of here the terrorists are going to think it was a win for them and it is going to embolden them. All the people who joined up knew the risks and if you joined just for college and didn't think you would get called up for duty you are an idiot.

bruce_s
03-27-2007, 08:06 PM
Thanks for your service low-mu and God speed to you and all the folks over there.There are way too many arm chair generals over here and its got to stop.

MSatt
03-27-2007, 08:20 PM
because Iraqi's are lazy as hell. If we don't pull out they are just gonna mooch off of us as much as they can and not do anything until they have to.

I was only there (al Assad) for 17 days last June, but this is the exact feeling that I left there with.

I, in no way, can compare what I do with the guys that spend months/years over there. Much respect!

Pirattitude
03-27-2007, 08:23 PM
At the end of the day, no matter if you believe in the war or not, you have to believe in men like that, who are over there protecting our freedom.

Mobile Diver
03-27-2007, 10:03 PM
Well I'm sitting here right now in Fallujah and agree with all of the things your friend said. Iraq is a long and slow process. I would say we are winning, even though all you see in the news is more Americans getting killed day by day. I look at the death toll once a week when I give a IED brief and this week alone in my area it was 5 U.S. KIA and 50 terrorist killed. I believe we need to continue building up Iraqi troops and then we need to pull out of here. Not because I don't agree with Iraq, which I do, but because Iraqi's are lazy as hell. If we don't pull out they are just gonna mooch off of us as much as they can and not do anything until they have to. As far as SOP's I'd say the terrorists are doing pretty good in that area as well. They video tape U.S. forces and know excatly what they can get away with. If one of them get's shot, all they have to do is throw down their gun and run around the corner, come at you from another direction and you have to give them medical aid. The media is the biggest problem. The terrorist's know about our secret counter measures because some jackass on late night news gives himself the title of expert and talks about things he shouldn't, on national television just for his fifteen minutes of fame and the poor marines who are put up for trial because a video of them executing a wounded insurgent when their buddies were blow up by a grenade in the same circumstance a day before. I'll I can say is be patient. If we just pull out of here the terrorists are going to think it was a win for them and it is going to embolden them. All the people who joined up knew the risks and if you joined just for college and didn't think you would get called up for duty you are an idiot.

More wisdom, more truth. Keep it coming!!!

Bill McIntyre
03-27-2007, 10:41 PM
I believe we need to continue building up Iraqi troops and then we need to pull out of here. Not because I don't agree with Iraq, which I do, but because Iraqi's are lazy as hell. If we don't pull out they are just gonna mooch off of us as much as they can and not do anything until they have to. ------------

I'll I can say is be patient. If we just pull out of here the terrorists are going to think it was a win for them and it is going to embolden them. All the people who joined up knew the risks and if you joined just for college and didn't think you would get called up for duty you are an idiot.

That seemed like a mixed message. If we don't pull out, the Iraqis won't take responsibility, but if we just pull out, the terrorists will win. So how do we know when to pull out?

I know you knew the risks and I'm proud of you, but I don't want to waste people like you. I bet your parents don't want to waste you either.

freedivingfool
03-28-2007, 07:28 AM
Hell yeah I can vouch for Hit, Iraq when i was there it was hot! We clear that whole city and blew up so many weapons cache, we found them all over that city. A bunch of contractors got ambush in that city and we had to go in and rescue them, but there's was nothing to rescue. We clear that city, and lost some good marines and navy corpmen there. so i'm extremely happy to hear that it's not as bad as some other places.

Low-Mu
03-28-2007, 08:42 AM
Bill, I can understand it seems like a mixed message and we do need to pull out of here but not yet. The Iraqi forces are not yet up to par. I'd say they are about 65% ready. Having forces stood up is one thing but having forces that can control areas, set up their own intel for targeting and manage logistics and supply issues is a whole other ball game. The line about the terrorists taking it as a win, now that I think about it, even if we pull out in 10 years the terrorist propoganda machine is still going to take it as a win but it would be far worse if the Iraqi government tumbles. That would be disasterous in my opinion.

Freedivingfool when you coming to relieve me? I can't wait for you to get through EOD school. You can teach me somethings about spearin and I'll teach you some shit about demo.

Gradyman
03-31-2007, 08:16 PM
It's good to hear it from "the horses mouth"...God bless you guys. I get so sick of the American media (Dems) propaganda machine...all accusations and gloom & doom with no solution but to "pull out" yesterday.